Step 2 · Overall feedback
An example overall feedback summary.
Alongside comments on specific passages, feedback includes a short overall summary. It names what is working, the single highest-value change and why that change matters — in plain language, without scores.
Example feedback summary
Overall feedback (fictional)
What is working: you write clearly at sentence level, and the social media example is relevant to the theme. The essay is easy to read, which many students never achieve.
The priority: commitment. Every key moment — the opening, the thesis, the conclusion of the paragraph — retreats to a neutral position. The essay observes the topic instead of arguing about it.
Why it matters: a committed position gives every paragraph a job. Once you argue that convenience has replaced effort in our relationships, the social media example stops being decoration and becomes evidence.
Next time: before writing, complete the sentence "This essay argues that…" and refuse to start until that sentence would survive a disagreement.
Example margin comments
This sentence is true of every essay ever written on this theme, so it does no work. Start where your thinking starts: which specific change in communication will this essay examine?
"Both positives and negatives" is a description, not a position. The essay needs a claim it is prepared to defend — for example, that convenience has quietly replaced effort in how we maintain relationships.
"Studies have shown" borrows authority the essay has not earned. You are allowed to reason from observation and experience — that is usually stronger here than a vague appeal to research.
"Complicated" is where the paragraph should begin thinking, not stop. What exactly is complicated, and what does that complication cost us? That answer is your next paragraph.